Wednesday, 27 March 2013

February / March tank winrates and OP Rating

Edit - this report is now also made as part of core NoobMeter functionality:
www.noobmeter.com/tankStats/


Time for another tank WR/OP report. This one was created using the www.noobmeter.com database for the battles between 1 February to 25 March, 2013 and is battle-weighted.

As before, I have included Player winrate (WR) for players which own a particular tank in the data, and also calculate a rating called "OP rating" which compares Tank WR with Player WR.

As you can see from the results, the new tanks are generally first played by the most skilled players. If one blindly evaluates new tanks using their WR, that can lead to incorrect conclusions. For example, just because tank X has 52% WR while other tanks in that category have 50% doesn't mean it is OP - perhaps it is simply played by players who on average have 54% WR, and is thus in fact under-performing!

This is why this report provides a more accurate picture.

Explanation of the columns:
  • Tank WR - victories / battles in percent for this particular tank 
  • Player WR - victories / battles in percent for players playing this tank 
  • OP Rating - Tank WR / Player WR - the higher the more OP
The t10 tanks all have poor OP ratings, I think that is because they are owned by the best players (good Player WR ratings), who can crush the low-tier random games against less experienced players, but then when playing t10 tanks they meet other good players - whether in CW, TC or even randoms, and thus no longer win that much.

Is this report representative for the whole WoT user set? Absolutely not, as mostly above-average players are interested in stats and thus likely to use NoobMeter (as you can see from the Player WR stats which are mostly around the 55% mark).

However, assuming you are a NoobMeter user it might very well be representative for you :).

If you have any concerns, please remain calm and write me a PM on the forums or comment on this blog and I will do my best to help. If in doubt, assume that there are no conspiracies involved. This applies to everything regarding NoobMeter, e.g., the clan filtering for newly added clan tops. :)

Level 10 MT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1Bat Chatillon 25 tFR470,17254.5%56.8%0.96
2T62ARU246,42654.3%57.2%0.95
3FV4202UK18,58855.0%58.6%0.94
4121CH10,37052.6%56.3%0.93
5M48A1US91,83653.8%57.9%0.93
6E-50 Ausf. MDE176,13952.8%57.0%0.93

Level 10 HT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1T57 HeavyUS91,48155.7%57.1%0.98
2T110E5US375,76454.6%56.4%0.97
3E-100DE307,19452.4%55.4%0.95
4113CH7,99052.4%55.6%0.94
5FV215bUK41,61853.6%57.3%0.94
6IS-4RU179,90752.2%56.1%0.93
7AMX 50BFR103,34053.3%57.6%0.93
8IS-7RU437,67251.0%55.3%0.92
9MausDE86,34850.4%55.9%0.90

Level 10 TD

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1AMX 50 Foch 155FR79,85556.1%57.5%0.98
2Object 268RU129,06154.6%57.2%0.96
3T110E3US49,54452.3%56.1%0.93
4T110E4US150,85152.3%56.7%0.92
5JagdPz E-100DE120,85850.5%55.6%0.91
6Object 263RU13,65752.2%57.6%0.91
7FV215b (183)UK86240.5%45.1%0.90

Level 9 MT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1WZ-120CH23,55456.5%56.6%1.00
2T54E1US93,23155.7%56.6%0.98
3T-54RU279,07354.8%55.8%0.98
4M46 PattonUS115,86754.5%56.4%0.97
5Centurion Mk.7UK58,30255.6%57.7%0.96
6E-50DE197,05152.8%55.6%0.95
7Lorraine 40 tFR155,77749.9%54.8%0.91

Level 9 HT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1WZ-111 model 1-4CH23,91455.8%56.1%0.99
2ST-IRU97,29952.9%54.5%0.97
3E-75DE434,63452.9%54.7%0.97
4Conqueror Mk.1UK127,29454.5%56.4%0.97
5M103US310,54452.8%55.0%0.96
6AMX 50 120FR134,37453.4%56.0%0.95
7IS-8RU397,88651.2%54.2%0.95
8VK 4502 (P) Ausf. BDE92,01851.5%54.7%0.94

Level 9 TD

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1Object 704RU182,20554.4%55.8%0.97
2AMX 50 FochFR75,11555.1%56.7%0.97
3T95US74,00853.0%55.3%0.96
4JagdtigerDE221,47852.3%55.2%0.95
5T30US162,38951.9%55.4%0.94
6SU-122-54RU42,83852.7%56.8%0.93
7TortoiseUK46552.5%57.0%0.92

Level 8 LT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1AMX 13 90FR406,06856.4%56.4%1.00
2WZ-132CH47,68454.9%56.5%0.97

Level 8 MT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1T69US155,51356.3%56.8%0.99
2CenturionUK101,17956.0%56.7%0.99
3T-44RU208,81953.2%54.7%0.97
4Type 59CH1,113,27653.7%55.5%0.97
5T26E4 SuperPershingUS616,48752.0%54.1%0.96
6T-34-2CH40,67353.9%56.0%0.96
7M26 PershingUS115,03953.1%55.6%0.96
8Panther IIDE134,14752.1%54.7%0.95

Level 8 HT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1110CH75,63757.7%56.2%1.03
2T32US367,61557.7%56.6%1.02
3IS-3RU1,131,02255.5%54.6%1.02
4AMX 50 100FR258,28957.8%56.9%1.02
5IS-6RU189,29954.3%53.5%1.01
6KV-5RU389,50754.1%54.6%0.99
7VK 4502 (P) Ausf. ADE112,39554.0%55.1%0.98
8CaernarvonUK157,31154.4%55.6%0.98
9KV-4RU152,45452.8%54.0%0.98
10PzKpfw VIB Tiger IIDE447,08352.4%54.2%0.97
11T34US1,621,36953.2%55.1%0.97
12FCM 50tFR70,13653.2%55.4%0.96
13M6A2E1US7,60456.6%59.3%0.95
14LöweDE752,43851.7%54.4%0.95

Level 8 TD

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1AT 15UK1,60755.5%54.8%1.01
2JagdPanther IIDE100,26353.3%55.2%0.97
3ISU-152RU205,68852.9%54.8%0.96
4FerdinandDE210,49452.3%54.2%0.96
5T28 PrototypeUS158,66952.3%54.2%0.96
6AMX AC Mle. 1948FR107,60653.4%55.9%0.96
7T28US61,37151.8%54.3%0.95
88.8 cm Pak 43 JagdTigerDE117,13650.6%54.1%0.94
9Uralmash-1RU49,80452.4%56.6%0.93

Level 8 SPG

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1Object 261RU190,57152.9%57.2%0.93
2T92US104,28851.9%57.0%0.91
3Bat Chatillon 155FR109,93051.3%56.5%0.91
4GW Typ EDE169,99851.0%56.3%0.91

Level 7 LT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1T71US278,60753.6%55.9%0.96
2WZ-131CH112,94653.0%55.4%0.96
3AMX 13 75FR132,48050.8%53.5%0.95
4Type-62CH41,84451.9%55.5%0.93

Level 7 MT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1T-34-1CH85,65056.4%55.9%1.01
2T-43RU135,66653.4%53.6%1.00
3T20US92,47154.6%55.0%0.99
4CometUK129,68954.3%54.9%0.99
5KV-13RU35,53552.8%53.6%0.99
6VK 3002 (DB)DE109,45454.9%56.5%0.97
7PzKpfw V PantherDE153,36652.3%54.3%0.96
8Panther M10DE44,85452.1%54.8%0.95

Level 7 HT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1T29US378,79857.0%54.8%1.04
2IS-2CH103,20157.5%56.0%1.03
3PzKpfw VI Tiger (P)DE201,24455.2%54.3%1.02
4Black PrinceUK136,99555.2%54.6%1.01
5ISRU346,83853.5%53.1%1.01
6KV-3RU85,31154.1%54.0%1.00
7PzKpfw VI TigerDE486,14653.0%53.6%0.99
8AMX M4 (1945)FR67,90553.2%54.6%0.98

Level 7 TD

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1AT 7UK1,32759.9%54.9%1.09
2SU-122-44RU194,57956.3%55.5%1.01
3T25 ATUS45,98754.0%54.5%0.99
4JagdpantherDE232,90553.6%54.2%0.99
5SU-100M1RU47,96954.3%55.1%0.98
6T25/2US142,36752.9%53.8%0.98
7SU-152RU115,77052.9%54.0%0.98
8AT 15AUK20,33353.6%54.9%0.98
9AMX AC Mle.1946FR71,79552.7%55.0%0.96

Level 7 SPG

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1Object 212RU225,93151.5%55.3%0.93
2M40/M43US150,29751.5%55.3%0.93
3GW TigerDE275,58250.3%54.4%0.92
4Lorraine155 51FR205,16651.9%56.2%0.92

Level 6 LT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1VK 2801DE164,15655.2%57.1%0.97
2AMX 12tFR178,25751.0%53.3%0.96
3T21US113,92051.6%54.3%0.95
459-16CH89,63651.4%54.8%0.94

Level 6 MT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1VK 3601 (H)DE409,75256.8%54.4%1.04
2CromwellUK224,26556.8%54.9%1.03
3T-34-85RU183,80955.6%53.9%1.03
4M4A3E8 ShermanUS73,13556.7%55.1%1.03
5M4A3E2US98,91255.8%54.9%1.02
6Type 58CH216,51455.3%55.3%1.00
7VK 3001 (P)DE98,00652.7%53.0%0.99
8VK 3001 (H)DE76,23853.8%54.1%0.99
9Pz IV SchmalturmDE70,53353.5%55.2%0.97
10PzKpfw V-IV AlphaDE6654.5%58.9%0.93
11PzKpfw V-IVDE1,91853.2%57.7%0.92

Level 6 HT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1KV-1SRU1,355,22057.3%54.0%1.06
2T-150RU133,45355.5%53.6%1.04
3KV-2RU191,42956.8%55.4%1.03
4M6US150,62254.6%53.4%1.02
5Churchill VIIUK116,23253.6%53.9%1.00
6ARL 44FR107,08253.7%54.1%0.99
7TOG IIUK23,96453.4%55.2%0.97

Level 6 TD

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1AT 8UK2,50960.5%55.1%1.10
2SU-100YRU1,77056.2%52.5%1.07
3M18 HellcatUS516,51158.9%55.0%1.07
4SU-100RU146,64255.8%54.2%1.03
5M36 SluggerUS53,81855.5%54.1%1.03
6JagdPz IVDE112,47451.9%52.6%0.98
7Dicker MaxDE107,34453.7%54.8%0.98
8Churchill Gun CarrierUK1,47152.2%53.6%0.97
9ARL V39FR94,33551.4%54.4%0.94

Level 6 SPG

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1S-51RU178,67454.3%55.6%0.98
2GW PantherDE486,40153.3%54.8%0.97
3Lorraine155 50FR279,01453.4%55.1%0.97
4M12US114,81952.0%54.1%0.96
5SU-14RU75,45851.6%54.0%0.95

Level 5 LT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1CrusaderUK69,45452.9%53.4%0.99
2ELC AMXFR238,61953.0%53.8%0.98
3VK 1602 LeopardDE92,79052.3%54.4%0.96
4M24 ChaffeeUS73,48254.7%57.0%0.96
5T-50-2RU232,90452.9%56.0%0.94

Level 5 MT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1M4 ShermanUS293,33360.3%55.6%1.09
2PzKpfw IVDE346,11657.7%54.4%1.06
3MatildaRU18,08357.7%54.7%1.05
4Ram-IIUS14,69757.5%55.6%1.03
5T-25DE124,69556.1%54.7%1.03
6T-34RU75,80453.9%53.4%1.01
7Matilda Black PrinceUK10,60855.3%55.1%1.00
8M4A2E4US8,38156.9%57.0%1.00
9T-34CH342,82053.9%54.1%1.00
10PzKpfw III/IVDE115,62952.0%52.6%0.99
11M7US76,04652.9%53.5%0.99

Level 5 HT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1T1 heavyUS110,71056.4%53.1%1.06
2KV-1RU534,12255.9%53.4%1.05
3KV-220 (action)RU5265.4%62.7%1.04
4Churchill IUK206,97255.8%54.1%1.03
5BDR G1BFR60,48355.1%53.7%1.03
6T14US48,13955.1%54.2%1.02
7ChurchillRU130,50255.0%54.7%1.00
8KV-220 Beta-TestRU6457.8%68.5%0.84

Level 5 TD

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1AT 2UK3,83256.6%53.0%1.07
2T49US143,01256.9%54.2%1.05
3M10 WolverineUS95,99556.3%53.8%1.05
4StuG IIIDE374,89155.5%53.7%1.03
5S-35 CAFR37,61455.8%54.7%1.02
6SU-85RU100,62553.9%53.3%1.01

Level 5 SPG

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1SU-8RU95,57254.0%53.7%1.01
2AMX 13 F3 AMFR115,93752.6%54.0%0.97
3M41US100,77951.9%53.5%0.97
4HummelDE263,67251.5%53.3%0.97

Level 4 LT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1PzKpfw II LuchsDE64,59657.4%54.1%1.06
2ValentineUK20,75353.2%52.9%1.01
3T-50RU248,97053.9%53.7%1.00
4M5A1 StuartCH146,46053.2%53.0%1.00
5CovenanterUK36,13753.2%53.1%1.00
6M5 StuartUS66,58053.9%53.9%1.00
7ValentineRU10,95455.2%55.3%1.00
8PzKpfw 38 nADE33,53051.0%51.8%0.98
9AMX 40FR17,84450.9%51.9%0.98
10A-20RU25,69750.0%51.4%0.97

Level 4 MT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1MatildaUK107,18959.2%53.8%1.10
2PzKpfw IIIDE101,24458.3%54.1%1.08
3A-32RU1,21861.6%57.5%1.07
4T-28RU68,22256.0%53.2%1.05
5M3 LeeUS55,07552.8%53.0%1.00

Level 4 HT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1PzKpfw B2 740 (f)DE18,63561.1%56.4%1.08
2B1FR16,78153.1%52.7%1.01

Level 4 TD

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1SU-85BRU50,24559.3%53.6%1.11
2HetzerDE185,25559.6%54.4%1.10
3T40US40,79859.3%54.2%1.09
4M8A1US36,32756.0%53.5%1.05
5Somua S-40FR20,33653.4%53.5%1.00
6AlectoUK4,81952.2%52.5%0.99

Level 4 SPG

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1GrilleDE325,61456.5%53.5%1.06
2SU-5RU57,94655.3%53.1%1.04
3AMX 105AMFR83,35053.6%53.3%1.01
4105 leFH18B2FR49,87354.6%55.0%0.99
5M7 PriestUS73,40851.8%52.7%0.98

Level 3 LT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1PzKpfw II Ausf. JDE4,29570.5%57.8%1.22
2PzKpfw 38 (t)DE34,97459.8%53.0%1.13
3T-15DE13,97961.8%55.9%1.11
4Cruiser Mk. IVUK18,89159.7%54.0%1.10
5T-127RU28,81661.9%56.2%1.10
6Pz.II Ausf.GDE1,24058.3%53.6%1.09
7Type 2597 Chi-HaCH48,60657.4%53.5%1.07
8Cruiser Mk. IIUK9,38758.3%54.7%1.06
9PzKpfw III Ausf. ADE22,74555.4%52.7%1.05
10Pz.I Ausf.СDE9,50755.0%52.7%1.04
11M3 StuartUS15,82054.8%52.6%1.04
12M22 LocustUS22,21857.5%55.3%1.04
13AMX 38FR5,71254.1%52.4%1.03
14T-46RU26,74252.6%52.4%1.00
15BT-7RU20,07252.0%52.2%1.00
16M3 Stuart LLRU9,96750.7%53.4%0.95

Level 3 MT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1PzKpfw S35 739 (f)DE46,15065.7%55.5%1.18
2M2 Medium TankUS20,44456.5%52.6%1.07
3D2FR5,18456.3%53.1%1.06
4Vickers Medium Mk. IIIUK5,68752.9%52.3%1.01

Level 3 TD

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1FCM36 Pak40FR47,06464.3%55.9%1.15
2Marder IIDE58,97958.7%54.3%1.08
3Renault UE 57FR9,44057.9%54.0%1.07
4SU-76RU16,44357.1%53.4%1.07
5T82US28,93657.6%54.7%1.05
6Valentine ATUK3,75952.9%51.8%1.02

Level 3 SPG

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1SU-26RU131,02962.7%55.9%1.12
2Lorraine39 L AMFR21,56756.8%52.9%1.07
3Sturmpanzer IIDE25,11053.1%51.9%1.02
4M37US20,33552.3%52.0%1.01
5WespeDE22,97853.1%52.9%1.00

Level 2 LT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1Cruiser Mk. IUK7,12864.7%54.5%1.19
2Cruiser Mk. IIIUK55,50665.5%55.4%1.18
3M2 Light TankUS24,40262.8%54.3%1.16
4PzKpfw IIDE97,92661.2%54.4%1.12
5PzKpfw 35 (t)DE33,23460.1%53.8%1.12
6PzKpfw 38H735 (f)DE59,71962.7%56.4%1.11
7BT-2RU53,84159.7%54.4%1.10
8MkVII TetrarchRU52,90162.0%56.7%1.09
9T-26RU14,72957.4%53.2%1.08
10Vickers Mk. ECH12,79056.5%54.0%1.05
11T2 Light TankUS73,50658.1%56.3%1.03
12Hotchkiss H35DE6,61855.1%53.8%1.02
13Pz.IDE85052.7%52.3%1.01
14T1 E6US120,93154.5%54.6%1.00
15D1FR1,72651.3%52.3%0.98

Level 2 MT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1T2 Medium TankUS8,53656.6%53.0%1.07
2Vickers Medium Mk. IIUK4,80753.6%52.9%1.01

Level 2 TD

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1Panzerjäger IDE27,73061.6%53.7%1.15
2T18US177,42061.0%54.8%1.11
3AT-1RU9,46658.4%53.8%1.09
4RenaultFT ACFR6,40957.6%53.8%1.07
5Universal Carrier 2-pdrUK1,15254.6%51.9%1.05

Level 2 SPG

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1Sturmpanzer I BisonDE24,22560.5%55.6%1.09
2T57US14,75856.5%52.6%1.07
3RenaultBSFR4,39052.2%52.5%0.99
4SU-18RU6,41551.2%52.1%0.98

Level 1 LT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1LeichttraktorDE181,10360.6%53.7%1.13
2MS-1RU62,48559.7%53.9%1.11
3T1 CunninghamUS194,75261.5%55.7%1.10
4Renault NC-31CH29,85156.8%53.4%1.06
5RenaultFTFR10,87055.1%52.8%1.04

Level 1 MT

#TankNationBattlesTank WRPlayer WROP rating
1Medium Mark IUK21,27256.7%53.4%1.06

10 comments:

  1. A question here. Does this data extracted from EU server only, or it's a merged data from all servers?

    As far as I know, different servers have different play styles, and thus single tank win rate sometimes differs from server to server. e.g. in NA server, M48 Patton has a WR of 48% while it performs better in RU server (around 51%).

    Considering this, if this is a merged data from all servers, I will personally suggest it may have a gap from what happens in each server.

    Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is EU server.

    However, I think the main gap is depending on what kind of players play the tank. For example, hypothetically, on Russian server every player wants to have T-54 while on US server every player wants a Patton. On the Russian server, however, only the good players want a Patton, and vice versa.

    So therefore Patton's WR is high on RU server but average on NA server. But the tank OP rating already accounts for that.

    ReplyDelete
  3. tortoise: player wr 57%
    fv(183): player wr 45,1%
    epic

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi,

    I understood the numbers of OP Rating when it was introduced giving results around 1.0 (tank WT / players WR). Could someone please explain the numbers which are used now (~ 400 to 600). How are they calculated?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "1000 * tank wr squared divided by players winrate"

      Delete
    2. ... sounds easy but please have a look at this example based on tank stats from today (July 1st):

      Maus: WR 53,7% Player WR 55,9%
      --> Based on your formula OP Rating should be
      1000 * 0.537 * 0.537 / 0.559 = 515.9
      (or: 1000 * 0.537² / 0.559 = 515.9)

      Result on your homepage 581.4 - quite different...

      I've checked it with several other tanks but this formular gives never the same result then your homepage...

      So for me it's still unclear how OP Rating is calculated

      Could you please try to explain your calculation once again? Thx!

      Delete
    3. It is also battle weighted. E.g., a player with 1000 recent battles in a particular tank impacts the OP rating a lot more than a player with 10 recent battles.

      Perhaps easiest to explain the details is if I send you the relevant code.

      Drop me an email at for_elr at noobmeter.com and I will send you the relevant parts.

      Delete
  5. Hi! As far as I see, current version of http://www.noobmeter.com/tankStats/ has an updated OP rating. Could you please explain how it is calculated and what OP Rating (Bad) and (Good) mean.

    ReplyDelete